Corsicana Daily Sun, Corsicana, Texas


April 4, 2014

Morgan: A union for college athletes just doesn't make sense

Corsicana — The football team at Northwestern University is now unionized. The move toward collective bargaining was approved by the Chicago Labor Relations Board.

There are two significant facts about that approval. Number one was that it was the “Chicago” Labor Relations Board. Chicago is run by unions. And, number two is that it was the Labor Relations Board.

The Labor Relations Board is dependent on the existence of unions for their existence. So, when asked if someone can unionize, the answer is DUH!

The push for a unionized football team in the Chicago suburb was initiated by the United Steelworkers’ Union. Why would the steelworkers be interested in advancing a union for a collegiate football team?

Do they think some of the players might be drafted by Pittsburgh? Over the past 20 plus years, union membership in this country has dropped from 16% down to 9%.

Unions are hurting which means the union’s political influence is waning. Growing any union is good for all unions.

So, are these players being exploited? Should they be paid for their efforts since the university is making money from the football season? Or, are they being paid already? Let’s start with the value of an education at Northwestern. In terms of strictly the cost of attending the Big Ten school, the annual tuition for 2013 was $43,380. If a player graduates in four years, they have been given $173,520 in education cost. That’s without even figuring in books, meals and room. So, are they going to bargain for spending money so they don’t have to shake hands with wealthy alumnus after a game(wink wink)?

My experience with unions has been minimal. Teachers in Texas do not have unions.

 I belonged to the Texas State Teachers Association for my first three years in the profession. After a vote failed in an attempt to merge with the National Education Association, and a new vote took place within three months, I dropped my TSTA membership. The NEA was as close to a union as I ever wanted to be.

In states that do have teachers unions, you see where members who are incompetent are protected by the union.

 In New York, they have convicted sex offenders who sit in “rubber rooms” while still drawing a paycheck. I would then assume that a player who can’t play would be entitled to keep his scholarship. In fact, they might force the coach to play him for a certain percentage of time.

Have you ever heard of featherbedding? As an example, in the railroad industry, when the technology went from coal fired steam engines to diesel fueled engines, the union refused to let the companies do away with the position of fireman, the guy who shoveled coal into the engine. So, if a team goes to a spread offense like almost everyone in the Big Twelve, would the union force them to keep a fullback even if he never played?

If a game goes into overtime, would the players demand time and a half? If a player is summoned to go into a game, could he refuse because it interferes with his 15 minute afternoon break guaranteed by the contract?

What if this unionization spills over into basketball? Could a future NBA player who has eight kids by six women demand a three day maternity leave for each child born, as is guaranteed in the major league collective bargaining agreement? If that’s the case, some college hoop seasons could be awfully short. March Madness could turn into Baby Momma Madness.

If SEIU workers decide to strike and picket college stadiums, would the players cross the picket line out of sympathy for their brothers in labor? “No justice, no popcorn.”

I feel for all those exploited college players. They get a free high dollar education … Let me rephrase that. They get an opportunity to get a fine education, although if you listen to a lot of them, many forgo that opportunity. Many exploit the experience to serve as a training ground for an NFL career.

Most find career networking opportunities among influential alumni even if they don’t play professionally. And the sorority ladies … well, that’s another story.

Perhaps we should just drop the charade. Maybe each college should give the players a choice: the education or the cash. It would cost the university the same amount, and it would tell you a lot about the foresight of the prospect. Make a lot now, or a lot more later?

Hmmm … I wonder if the Chicago Labor Relations Board bothered to mention the term “union dues” to these guys? I’ll bet not. Discovering that the right to organize isn’t cheap, might change their view.

Text Only
  • 7-31-14 Jae.jpg GC Volleyball Summer Tour: Frost set for a big season

    Everybody's back at Frost.
    Yes, everybody.
    “This will probably never happen again,'' said Frost volleyball Coach Elaine Woods, who returns every player from last year's team.
    They are not only back, but they are talented — arguably the most talented group of volleyball players in Frost history.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • 7-30-14 Davis.jpg Former Cowboy Keith Davis delivers motivational speech

    Keith Davis believes in dreams.
    He lived his.
    That was one of the messages Davis, a former Dallas Cowboys safety, delivered to a standing-room-only crowd of youngsters Tuesday at the Boys & Girls Club, where he spoke with enthusiasm and energy about life inside and outside of the NFL.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • 7-30 web Wortham TTBA picture.jpg TTBB: Wortham takes second at state tournament

    The Wortham Bulldogs made an impressive run at the Texas Teenage Baseball Association High School Eligible State Tournament in Buffalo and took second in the state.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • 7-29-14 tiger sharks.jpg Tiger Sharks make splash at state meet

    There are leaps and bounds, and then there's what the Corsicana YMCA Tiger Sharks did over the weekend at the Lone Star state swimming meet in Frisco.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • 7-27 Shimonek all-star.jpg Mildred's Shimonek transferring from Iowa, will walk on at Texas Tech

    Former Mildred quarterback and Golden Circle Del Thrash Player of the Year Nic Shimonek is leaving the University of Iowa after one red-shirt year and transferring to Texas Tech because of Iowa's pro-style offense.

    July 28, 2014 2 Photos

  • GC Baseball/Softball: Mildred names Zamzow new baseball coach; AD Chambliess to coach softball again

         The Mildred Eagles didn’t have to go far to find a new baseball coach to replace Aaron Tidwell, who left the diamond to take the job as the principal of Mildred High School.
        On Saturday, Mildred named softball coach Brett Zamzow its new baseball coach as Zamzow, who was Tidwell's assistant for five years,  moves back to baseball after spending a year coaching softball.
        To complete the move Mildred Athletic Director Billy Dan Chambliess will take over the softball team. Chambliess, who is the head football coach, spent fours years coaching softball before becoming the school’s AD last year. All four of his teams won district titles.

    July 26, 2014

  • RON MORGAN.jpg Morgan; Remembering House and a better era

    The Cowboys started training camp the same week that Robert Newhouse died.
    In a way, that’s very unfortunate for Jerry. Thinking back to the “Human Bowling Ball” and the teams of that era might lead to the inevitable comparisons to today’s product on the field.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • weights.jpg GC Football: Blooming Grove's Williams expects to win

    His father was a head coach for years at Pecos High and his brother-in-law is the head football coach at DeSoto, but Lawrence Williams Jr., a man who loves coaching football, never had any ideas about being the head man.
    “I love coaching,'' said Williams as he sat at his desk in Blooming Grove, where he became the Lions' head coach this summer. “I just never thought about being the head coach and I never applied to be a head coach. With this job I can still coach.''

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Kevin Reese mug.jpg Outdoors: Kevin Reese: Summer time means summer tracking

    With only two months before opening day of archery season you should already have your bow maintenance complete, be shooting daily and chomping at the bit for our favorite day to arrive!
    Let’s face it, few animals turn our rotors like whitetail deer.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • All-State Baseball: Corsicana's Harlan and Wolver honored on TSWA/Collin Street Bakery 4A All-State Baseball team

    Corsicana junior Brady Harlan and sophomore Layton Wolver were honored on the Texas Sports Writers Association/Collin Street Bakery Class 4A All-State Baseball team that was announced Tuesday night.

    July 22, 2014

House Ads
AP Video
Netanyahu Vows to Destroy Hamas Tunnels Obama Slams Republicans Over Lawsuit House Leaders Trade Blame for Inaction Malaysian PM: Stop Fighting in Ukraine Cantor Warns of Instability, Terror in Farewell Ravens' Ray Rice: 'I Made a Huge Mistake' Florida Panther Rebound Upsets Ranchers Small Plane Crash in San Diego Parking Lot Busy Franco's Not Afraid of Overexposure Fighting Blocks Access to Ukraine Crash Site Dangerous Bacteria Kills One in Florida Workers Dig for Survivors After India Landslide Texas Scientists Study Ebola Virus Smartphone Powered Paper Plane Debuts at Airshow Southern Accent Reduction Class Cancelled in TN
Twitter Updates